[2018] 4 MLRA 1
Federal Court, Putrajaya
Hasan Lah, Azahar Mohamed, Zaharah Ibrahim, Balia Yusof Wahi, Jeffrey Tan FCJJ
[Civil Appeals Nos: 01-60-12-2015 & 01-1-01-2016]
Hasan Lah, Azahar Mohamed, Zaharah Ibrahim, Balia Yusof Wahi, Jeffrey Tan FCJJ


Jeffrey Tan FCJ:

[1] These appeals arose from the decision of the Court of Appeal dated 2 July 2015 which reversed the decision of the trial court and allowed all claims by the plaintiff. For ease of reference, we would refer to the parties as plaintiff (Batu Kemas Industri Sdn Bhd), 1st defendant (Kerajaan Malaysia) and 2nd defendant (Tenaga Nasional Berhad).

[2] The plaintiff's factory (factory) at Lot 2795, Jalan Tanjong Malim - Slim River, Perak used automated hydraulic presses and other electronically controlled machinery to produce calcium silicate bricks. The 2nd defendant supplied electricity to the factory whereat was a power substation.

[3] The Public Works Department (PWD) had appointed Markas Perdana Sdn Bhd (Markas) to execute works at the rest and recreation area at the 106km Ipoh to Kuala Lumpur highway. On 13 October 1997, the PWD handed the project site to Markas. On 31 October 1997, 9 January 1998, and 27 February 1998, the PWD requested the 2nd defendant to remove and relocate the electrical lines and cables from the project site. But the underground cable was not removed or relocated. Then disaster struck. On 5 August 1998, in the course of its installation at the R&R area, a guard rail column struck and ruptured the 1st defendant's 11KV cable. Power to the factory was disrupted. The plaintiff claimed that the power disruption damaged its manufacturing equipment and processes and caused general, special and exemplary damages.

Sign up to view full cases Login